November 18, 2025

Why Order Accuracy Matters More Than Faster Shipping
Next-day delivery gets the headlines. But ask most customers whether they'd prefer their order a day faster or definitely right, and you know the answer.
A parcel that arrives quickly with the wrong size inside isn't a fast delivery. It's the start of a returns process, a second shipment and, quite often, a customer who doesn't come back.
Work out what a mispick actually costs
It's worth putting rough numbers on this, because the cost of a wrong order is usually much higher than people assume. Take an imaginary clothing brand with a £45 average order:
return postage for the wrong item: around £3 to £4
a second pick, pack and dispatch for the right item: £4 to £6 including postage
receiving and checking the returned item: £1 or so
customer service time to deal with the complaint: ten to fifteen minutes of someone's day
any goodwill discount or voucher you offer to smooth it over
That can easily come to £10 for a single mistake, before you count the customer who quietly decides not to order again. On a 2% error rate and 5,000 orders a month, that's 100 unhappy customers and well over £1,000 a month in direct costs.
A percentage can hide a lot
Most 3PLs quote picking accuracy as a percentage, often 99% or higher. That sounds reassuring, but it's only meaningful if you know what's being counted.
Ask how the figure is calculated. Does it include:
the wrong variant (right style, wrong size or colour)?
short shipments, where one item from a multi-line order is missing?
missing inserts, gifts or promotional items?
items damaged because they were packed badly?
Ask too whether it's measured per order or per item. A 99.5% item-level rate can be a much lower order-level rate if your customers typically buy three or four things at once.

Accuracy comes from the process, not from people trying harder
Good pickers make mistakes when the system makes it easy to. The things that really reduce errors are dull but effective:
Barcode scanning at pick and pack: If the picker scans the item and the system checks it against the order, a lot of errors never leave the shelf.
Clean product data: Every variant needs its own barcode and a clear description. Two near-identical products sharing a barcode, or a barcode that was never set up properly, will cause mistakes, however careful the team is.
Sensible locations: Separating lookalike products, such as the navy and black versions of the same jumper, makes a real difference.
Clear instructions: Bundles, gift notes, inserts and promotional add-ons need to be visible on the pick list, not buried in an email from three weeks ago.
Treat errors as something to fix together
When a mistake does happen, the useful question isn't "whose fault was it?" but "why did it happen, and will it happen again?" Was it a data problem, a location problem, a packing problem or a one-off?
A good fulfilment partner will log errors, look for patterns and tell you about them. Equally, brands can help by keeping product data and images up to date and flagging new launches early. If your returns data shows a cluster of "wrong item received" against one product, that's worth a joint look. Our post on inventory accuracy goes into the stock side of this in more detail.
What to ask a fulfilment provider about accuracy
How do you define and measure picking accuracy, and can we see our own figures monthly?
Is every item scanned at pick and at pack?
How do you handle products that look alike?
When an error is reported, how quickly is the correct item sent, and who pays?
Want fewer wrong orders? We started 33 Fulfilment after running e-commerce brands ourselves, so we know what a mispick does to a customer relationship. Talk to us about how we pick, check and report.
Have additional questions?
Related posts





